|Kabul: 16:13 PM      |
Welcome to Kabul:Reconstructions. You can follow the information below, which has been gathered from a
number of sources by a number of participants (click on the names at left for bios), to reconstruct your
own picture of events in Kabul since this site was launched on March 8th, 2003 and, in a sense, since the
reconstruction of Afghanistan began somewhere in the winter of 2001-02.
Some of this information has been provided in response to specific questions submitted by visitors like you. Please note that this section of the project is now maintained as an archive and has not been updated since 2005. Click here to ASK A QUESTION.
Arian Mouj Sharifi
Hi all, sorry for the delay in posting more press on the Constitutional Loya Jirga, but I was actually there for two weeks and didn't have time to read through everything. Then when I did was kind of shocked at the disparity between most of what I read and what I had seen on the ground myself. Am posting some of the more interesting articles as a record of this, will follow up with some of my own footage later -- meanwhile, supplementing the articles with stills from my video to give you some of the texture of the event. -- mariam
The Hindu (India) December 18, 2003 THE LOYA JIRGA Robert O. Blake, Jr., Charge d'Affaires, U.S. Embassy, New Delhi. WINDS of change are sweeping across Afghanistan.'s fertile river valleys, deep gorges, deserts, and snow-covered mountains. After a quarter-century of war, Soviet occupation and extremism, the Afghan people are enjoying new freedoms and restored liberties. For the first time in decades, the country is largely at peace. During the last two years, Afghanistan has reached many social, economic and political milestones: an internationally recognised government is in power; schools have reopened; a new banking law is in place; a new currency replaced the many previously in circulation; the road from Kabul to Kandahar is now paved; businesses are blossoming around the country; and - most importantly - Afghans have renewed hope and optimism.This month, Afghanistan marks its next important political milestone by taking a dramatic step toward becoming a moderate, representative and Islamic republic that values the welfare of its citizens: Afghanistan is ratifying its new constitution. This week, a 500-person constitutional Loya Jirga (great council) convened to deliberate upon and adopt a new constitution. Just as America's founding fathers gathered in Philadelphia over two centuries ago to build political consensus, give shape to their political institutions and enshrine the values of a new republic at the Constitutional Convention, so too, are the Afghans embarking on a process to craft a constitution that celebrates their culture and represents their highest aspirations. This process was put into motion in October 2002 when President (Hamid) Karzai created a nine- member Constitutional Drafting Commission. In April 2003, a 35-member Constitutional Review Commission, including seven women delegates, undertook revisions. The Commission started public consultations in June and, through a series of town meetings, sought the views of tens of thousands of Afghans across the country and from refugee communities in Iran and Pakistan. After drafting and consulting with a cross-section of Afghans for over a year, the Afghan Government unveiled the draft constitution on November 3. On December 14, a constitutional Loya Jirga , that represents Pashtuns, Tajiks, Uzbeks, Hazaras, Nuris, Turcomans, Baluchis, and other ethnic groups and includes 89 women delegates, began deliberating upon and eventually will adopt a new constitution. To emphasise the importance of civil society participation in this process, President Karzai decreed that militia commanders and government officials will not participate. The draft constitution provides for a bicameral legislature, with an upper and lower house. Members of the Wolesi Jirga , or lower house, will be elected for five-year terms. The upper house, or Meshrano Jirga , will consist of a mix of appointed and elected members. One- sixth of its representatives will be women, appointed by the president. The National Assembly will promulgate laws, ratify treaties, approve budgets, and question Ministers in the Government. The constitution also establishes a strong presidential system. To become President of Afghanistan, a candidate must receive 50 per cent of the popular vote, or a runoff election will take place between the top two candidates. The President, eligible to serve two five-year terms, is both the head of state and the head of government. The constitution also divides the country into provinces, each governed by a provincial council with the members elected to four- year terms. Each village and district will also have councils and members elected to three-year terms. In addition to outlining the structure of government, the draft constitution establishes protections for human rights. It provides for basic rights and freedoms and specifically recognises Afghanistan's obligation to abide by international human rights treaties it has signed. The draft also recognises the important role of Islam in Afghanistan without prohibiting the practice of other religions. Finally, the constitution establishes a single Supreme Court with high courts and appeals courts. There are no separate religious courts. Courts will apply the constitutional and other laws; however, if no provision applies, they may decide issues based on Islamic jurisprudence. India and the United States share common goals for Afghanistan. We both want Afghanistan to succeed in becoming a moderate, democratic country with good relations with all of its neighbours and are both providing assistance toward this end. India has taken a number of important steps to support Afghanistan's reconstruction, including committing $ 170 million, negotiating a Preferential Trade Agreement, and actively supporting the rebuilding of the infrastructure sector, including the laying of roads. India also provided the Government of Afghanistan 60 electronic voting machines to support its effort to build a better democratic process. The United States, for its part, continues to fulfil its role as a friend to Afghanistan by helping rebuild infrastructure in a number of areas, ranging from schools to hospitals to irrigation canals for farming, the livelihood of the vast majority of Afghans. The reconstruction of Afghanistan marked an important milestone on December 16 with the official reopening of the 482-kilometre stretch of highway connecting the capital Kabul with the main southern city, Kandahar. We have also provided $ 14.5 million to support the constitutional process and joined Afghan leaders in seeking additional support from the international community for Afghanistan's democratic transition. We have consulted closely with the Afghan Government throughout the process. The United States supports the democratic efforts that respect human rights of all ethnic and religious groups in Afghanistan. However, let us be clear: this constitutional process derives its legitimacy from the fact that it has been an Afghan process from the beginning. As with the U.S. Constitution, the Constitution of Afghanistan is designed to be a document of the people, by the people and for the people of Afghanistan. Afghans respect the traditional value of Loya Jirgas and their decisions are binding. This week, we are seeing Afghanistan determine its own destiny as it undertakes a democratic approach to ascertain the will of the nation. The resulting constitution will establish a democratic government in keeping with the unique cultural values of the Afghan people. Talking about a constitution Dec 18th 2003 | KABUL From The Economist print edition THE grand assembly, or loya jirga, appointed to promulgate Afghanistan's new constitution—and set its democratic future—began, on December 14th, with tears. Some children sang a lament to their nation: “Everyone in his turn has broken your heart.” Yes indeed, and many of them were sitting in the front row. Two years after the fall of the Taliban, one can hardly look at Afghanistan and not reflect on things to come in Iraq. At least Saddam Hussein has been dragged out of his hole; Osama bin Laden is still at large. Afghanistan has yet to resolve its power struggles, and the resulting insecurity means that large portions of the country are off-limits to aid workers. The country exports little but opiates, and a reconstructed Afghanistan—let alone a prosperous one—still seems a very long way off. If anything, the loya jirga confirmed one truth: Afghanistan will be rebuilt only with the acquiescence of warlords and drug pushers. Centre-stage was clean enough. The president of the transitional government, Hamid Karzai, sat next to the 89-year-old former king, Zahir Shah, now reduced to the symbolic role of “father of the nation”. The monarch gave a tidy speech, in effect winding up a kingship which began in 1933 and sputtered on in exile after he was deposed in 1973. Mr Karzai, on the other hand, missed a golden opportunity. Instead of something snappy and passionate, he issued a dreary progress report, the finer points of which were lost on less literate delegates. There are 500 delegates in all, from across the country. A fifth are women. But it is unclear what influence, if any, the delegates will really have over shaping the final version of the constitution, most of which had been negotiated before they made it to Kabul. The biggest issue is political: should Afghanistan have a parliamentary or, as the draft now has it, a centralised presidential system? Mr Karzai made his own views clear. He told delegates he would not run in next year's elections if they chose a parliamentary system. Afghanistan is too immature to deal with a division of powers, and the might of regional warlords militates against the federalism some would favour, he reckons. Most of his ministers agree. They would like to see two vice-presidents; or maybe three, which would keep the factions happy while helping to tie them to the centre. An exception is the defence minister, Mohammed Fahim, who quite fancied being prime minister. He now seems resigned to sticking to his defence portfolio and giving up a bit more of his private army, on the unspoken understanding that no one looks too carefully into his business affairs. Still, Mr Fahim is not to be underestimated. He showed savvy in turning up to the loya jirga in the get-up of a jihadi commander, an image reminiscent of the struggle against the Soviet occupation that ordinary Afghans appreciate. The national anthem turned out to be a sticking point for many Pushtun delegates; they resent seeing their language usurped by Dari, the local variant of Persian, and would like more power at the expense of Mr Fahim and other northerners. But they are divided on the question of the monarchy, which some of them would like to revive, and on Taliban moderates, whom some want to see brought back into the fold. Many Pushtun delegates, when interviewed in a quiet corner, revealed reservations about Mr Karzai. But most said they will throw their hat in with him and a strong presidency; he may be Americanised, but Mr Karzai is still a Pushtun. The danger is that in tailoring a presidency to suit Mr Karzai, Afghanistan is putting all its eggs in one basket. What if something should happen to him? What if he wins next year's election and goes to ground or turns bad, or else is beaten by a candidate from the thuggish school of Afghan politics? No one, though, has come up with a better alternative. Another question to be settled by delegates is what sort of legal code Afghanistan should have. Judicial reform, overseen by Italian officials, has been messy. The government has skated over the issue, to its peril. The 1964 constitution called for laws “in keeping with the principles of Islam”. The new jihadi-fuelled draft calls for “laws in keeping with Islam”. A subtle change, but a worrying one for human-rights advocates. There are large bits of the legal code, they fear, to which sharia—or Islamic law—punishments such as amputation and stoning could be applied. Even more worrisome is the manoeuvring of Abdul Rasul Sayyaf, a conservative and piratical warlord, to head the new judiciary. Delegates appeared aghast at the thought, but a few ministers hinted a deal might be in the offing.
Afghanistan's fate hangs in balance 19 December 2003 2:10 AM Bangkok Post (Thailand) Representatives from right across Afghanistan are meeting in the capital Kabul to debate the country's new constitution. The draft contains 160 separate articles. With 502 delegates covering the entire spectrum of Afghan society in attendance, the task will be a torturous one indeed. Exacerbating the difficulties are long-held traditional views, recent wars and often violent squabbling. Despite international pleas to delegates to put the past aside and consider the future when debating this constitution, this has been virtually impossible. Traditional views raised their ugly head early on. After chairman Sebaghatullah Mojadeddi announced there would be three deputy chairmen, 13 men and three women contested the posts, and three men were elected. The 100-odd females present protested there should be at least one woman as deputy because while women make up only 25% of the grand assembly, they comprise 50% of the population. Mr Mojadeddi, a former president and religious scholar, responded correctly that delegates had to respect the vote. ``Women are free to vote for men,'' he said. ``Men are free to vote for women. We cannot make this separation.'' But after more pressure from the floor, his upbringing overrode his dexterity and he made the assembly's first faux pas. ``Don't try to put yourself on a level with men. Even God has not given you equal rights because under his decision two women are counted as equal to one man,'' he blurted. Although thought a moderate, Mr Mojadeddi was raised under sharia law, which states that the testimony of two women in most cases is equivalent to that of one man. In one breath, he incurred the wrath of the women and modern-thinking male delegates and exposed the great difficulties the grand assembly is facing in trying to overcome ingrained traditional beliefs. After some heated words and a threat by the women to walk out, Mr Mojadeddi announced the grand assembly would have four deputy chairmen instead, one of them a woman. Safiqa Sadiqi of Jalalabad was selected. Just two days later, as the delegates were about to split into 10 groups to better debate the first 40 articles of the draft, another comment exposed the fragility of the peace inside the tent serving as the assembly's venue. Malalai Joya, a female delegate from western Farah province, criticised the mujahideen and called for them to be put on trial. The mujahideen had resisted the Russian invaders two decades ago. Troops needed to keep the peace as dozens of angry mujahideen rushed the stage to demand that Ms Joya be expelled. Those loyal to the Taliban are also still a worrying presence in Afghanistan, and while peace and security have returned to Kabul, under the watchful eye of international peacekeepers, the rest of the country, especially the south and near the Pakistan border, remains a lawless and violent land. Delegates to the grand assembly, or loya jirga, have shown that it will take more than a constitution for Afghanistan to become a united nation. It will also take more than the eradication of Taliban remnants and the calming of fighting warlords. It will take a generation, or perhaps longer, for Afghanistan to purge itself of its deep, traditional beliefs and scars from past civil wars and conflicts. The ousting of the Taliban was a significant, but only tiny, start on a road which will be long, treacherous, undulating and full of potholes. While the international community can help supply the road- making materials and some form of constitution can set the rules, the smoothness of that road will ultimately be decided by how quick Afghans can overcome prejudices and work together as one.
10 committees with its leadership Under Tent of Loya Jerga First committee is leading by Ustad Rabani Second committee is leading by Ustad Sayaf Third committee is leading by Ahmand Nabi Muhammadi (son Moulawee Nabi Muhammadi) Fourth committee is leading by Mohammad Tahir Fifth committee is leading by Ayatullah Muhsini Sixth committee is leading by Moulawee Gul Muhammad Seventh committee is leading by Dr.Mashahed Eight committee is leading by Ahmad Farid (son in law of Eng. Hekmatyar) Night committee is leading by Hashmat Ghani Ahmad Zai (brother of Finance Minister) Tenth committee is leading by Moulawee said Mohammad Hanif One Journalist and one secretariat have been appointed for each group.
Afghan assembly seen on the verge of deadlock By Sayed Salahuddin KABUL, Afghanistan (Reuters) - Afghanistan's constitutional assembly appeared on the verge of deadlock Thursday as scores of delegates protested for a second day against sweeping powers sought by President Hamid Karzai. Francesc Vendrell, the European Union's envoy for Afghanistan, said it was essential for the war-torn country's stability to adopt a document with broad support. About 150 members of the 502-delegate Loya Jirga, or Grand Assembly, are insisting on a vote on the type of regime Afghanistan will have before debating Karzai's proposed draft constitution, several of the protest leaders said. "The jirga is heading toward deadlock," said Karim Aimaq, a former mayor of Kabul, and a leader of the protesters. "Delegates have refused to participate in group discussions on Mr Karzai's draft for a second day running." Karzai has strong international backing and is widely seen as the only leader able to hold the country together. He needs only a simple majority to endorse the draft constitution intended to take Afghanistan to its first general elections next year and has vowed he will run for re-election only if there is a strong presidential system. The protesters are demanding a stronger parliament with a prime minister to dilute presidential powers. CONSENSUS IMPORTANT Vendrell said consensus was important. "It is essential for the country's stability that the constitution should have ample support," he told Reuters. "The constitution is not a government program, it is a document supposed to last for a considerable amount of time, and therefore it is essential that there should be some consensus amongst the Afghans about the kind of government they want." The protest was launched mainly by sections of the Northern Alliance group of commanders, who helped topple the Taliban regime in 2001. They are led by former President Burhanuddin Rabbani and Gen. Abdul Rashid Dostum, an ethnic Uzbek warlord. The alliance forms the backbone of Karzai's government after helping U.S.-led forces overthrow the Taliban in 2001, but now appears split over presidential powers. As the confrontation heated up, foreign journalists were barred from covering the Loya Jirga for a second day and state-controlled television stopped live coverage when a delegate stood up to voice his opposition. Opponents accuse Karzai and his U.S. allies of arm-twisting and buying off opponents with promises of future government roles, a tactic that seems to have won over some key Alliance figures and many Pashtuns, Afghanistan's largest ethnic group. The Loya Jirga has been held amid heavy security after threats by Taliban guerrillas to disrupt the assembly. Interior Minister Ali Ahmad Jalali said security measures had so far prevented this, although a number of bombs had been defused around the country, including one found Wednesday outside a Chinese restaurant frequented by foreigners. Earlier this week, three rockets landed in Kabul, but caused no damage or casualties. As with similar incidents in the past, government officials were quick to blame the Taliban, but international peacekeepers have said they are still investigating. 12/18/03 09:54 ET
Far Eastern Economic Review
December 17th. 2003
Afghanistan: Let's Make A Democracy; In order to secure the kind of
government he seeks, President Hamid Karzai may need to make some
concessions to the opposition
By Ahmed Rashid/Kabul
In a contentious and colourful political gathering that will
determine the future shape of Afghanistan, President Hamid Karzai is
directly confronting the greatest challenge to his authority since he
was elected last year.
The loya jirga, or grand assembly, opened on December 14, after a
three-month delay, to debate and ratify a new constitution that will
allow the government to hold presidential and parliamentary elections
Two years after the United States military drove the Taliban from
power, Karzai, with American backing, wants the assembly of delegates
from all over Afghanistan to approve a centralized presidential
democracy. His opponents would like a parliamentary system that
avoids giving too much power to a single leader, and say that
Afghanistan is not ready for early elections anyway.
In an enormous white tent heated against the bitter winter cold, 400
men and 100 women-450 elected delegates and 50 Karzai appointees-are
meeting, dressed in a mesmerizing array of costumes and headgear
symbolizing their ethnic affiliations. From this group, Karzai needs
a simple majority to pass the constitution, and he is expected to
succeed-with some concessions.
In the final few days before the start of a gathering that could last
two weeks, American diplomats and Karzai's officials worked around
the clock to swing blocks of delegates to their side by offering
their leaders concessions on other parts of the constitution. Several
of Karzai's ministers complained that Karzai had not carried out
sufficient political lobbying among the delegates before the loya
Nearly half of the delegates, joined in several opposition groups,
oppose the presidential system outlined in the draft constitution.
Instead they seek a parliamentary system with a president and a prime
minister, a more powerful parliament and greater provincial autonomy.
In the past 35 years Afghanistan has gone through a monarchy, a
republic and communist and Islamic regimes.
In Afghanistan, "the balance of power is not favourable to the
centre. The centre needs to get stronger," says U.S. Ambassador to
Afghanistan Zalmay Khalilzad. "But where the balance is has to be
decided by the loya jirga," he says. "If adjustments [to the draft]
need to be made, this is what democracy is all about. It's a big test
but I am sure the Afghans will pass."
The most powerful opposition group comprises some 100 delegates from
ethnic minorities in the north and northeast-Uzbeks, Tajiks, Turkmens
and Hazaras-who have temporarily buried their rivalries to oppose the
presidential system. The northern opposition has been joined by
groups of Islamic fundamentalist delegates from the west and
provinces around Kabul, and monarchists and democrats who also oppose
the presidential system.
On the other side of the ethnic divide, most Pashtuns, the majority
ethnic group, support the presidential system and Karzai, who is also
The fundamentalists are demanding more Islamic law and control of the
judiciary, while the northern groups want greater provincial autonomy
and the direct election of provincial governors.
Karzai is likely to offer some small concessions in order to persuade
these groups to accept his presidential democracy. However, there are
"Some of these concessions, like fundamentalist control of the
judiciary, may prove detrimental for the rule of law in the long
term," says John Sifton of Human Rights Watch.
Unfortunately, rule of law holds little sway over much of
Afghanistan. The Karzai government sees the loya jirga as an
opportunity to further legitimize its attempts to disarm the warlords
who control parts of the country and wield considerable influence in
the central government. Doing so would help Karzai persuade the
international community to provide more troops and money for security
and reconstruction, which would also ease voter registration and the
election process. The U.S. has committed $1.2 billion for Afghanistan
this financial year, doubling the amount pledged earlier, while no
European country has increased spending.
Security concerns were all too clear in Kabul as the assembly opened
the protection of some 8,000 foreign and Afghan troops, in case, says
Interior Minister Ali Jalali, "the terrorists-the Taliban or Al Qaeda-
a suicide-bomb attack or fire rockets from the surrounding hills."
Despite the dangers, 87% of representatives showed up to vote. And at
opening, tension also came from within, as nearly 200 delegates
petition to hold a national referendum on choosing a system of
change the loya jirga's rules of procedure, cancel voting rights for
delegates nominated by Karzai and turn the loya jirga into a permanent
shura, or Islamic council.
"Karzai wants a dictatorship which people will not accept," says
Abdul Hafiz Mansur, a leader of the former Northern Alliance and the
head of state-owned Afghan radio and TV. "The draft [constitution]
changed 22 times, all through Karzai's dictates, and there are no
open for the delegates," he claims.
Karzai however argues for centralized power. "In countries where
no strong institutions, in countries where there are remnants of a
we need a system that will run with one centrality, not many centres
power," he said at the loya jirga's opening.
In the first few days of the assembly, as Karzai, his supporters and
diplomats bargained with delegates, the opposition weakened
When democracy will take hold remains uncertain. The reconstruction
process stipulated in 2001 by the UN Bonn accords called for
elections by June, 2004. The UN's special representative for
Afghanistan, Lakhdar Brahimi, now says that the country won't be
ready for elections by then. "Because of the security situation in
the south of the country, we will have to revise our plans," he
says. "You could have presidential elections by [autumn] but not
The Americans and Karzai are now keen to see presidential elections by
September, with parliamentary elections to follow later when the
security situation improves.
Many Afghans as well as the UN, European governments and Western and
Afghan aid groups are opposed to rushing the elections. "The security
situation has to improve and real reconstruction start before
elections can be held," says Vice-President Amin Arsala.
Even Karzai admits that "we have reached 40%-50% of the administrative
ability that a government in a country like ours should have."
However, Karzai and his group strongly support early elections. "We
need elections in order to have legitimacy and a mandate for changes
the country needs," says Finance Minister Ashraf Ghani.
In the build-up to the loya jirga, the Taliban stepped up their
assassinations and kidnappings of foreign aid workers and contractors
and their attacks on U.S. and Afghan soldiers in southern
December 2, the U.S. military launched Operation Avalanche, a major
offensive in seven southern and eastern provinces "in order to keep
the enemy on the hop in case they planned to disrupt the loya jirga,"
says a senior U.S. military officer.
However, public resentment against U.S. forces has intensified after
two separate bungled aerial bombings of villages killed 15 Afghan
children and two adults in eastern Afghanistan in the first week of
The dire security situation was highlighted by UN Secretary General
Kofi Annan. "Unchecked criminality, outbreaks of factional fighting
and activities surrounding the illegal narcotics trade have all had a
negative impact," he said on December 8 at the UN.
Validating the constitution is only one obstacle in the long battle
for Afghans seeking to restore stability to their country.
Kabul: Partial Reconstructions is an installation
and public dialogue project that explores the multiple meanings and resonances of
the idea of reconstruction -- as both process and metaphor -- in the context of present-day Kabul.
www.kabul-reconstructions.net is an online discussion forum, information resource, and medium for the communication of questions and answers about the reconstruction between people inside and outside the city of Kabul itself.